Wash your oxtail pieces with your choice of lemon/vinegar and water. Rinse and drain until water becomes more clear than it is reddish in color. Drain the excess water and pat the meat dry.
Cut off the excess fat (white portions) from the meat as much as you can.
Season the oxtail with all powder and liquid seasonings. Do not use the ground seasonings as yet. Allow to marinate overnight if possible, if not try for at least 1 hour. It will still taste great if you do not do this but I always like for the seasoning to soak as much as possible. It heightens the flavor!
On medium level, heat vegetable oil in a deep sauce pan. The pan needs to be deep enough so that once you add water, the oxtail has enough room to get a proper stew.
Wait until the pot is heated. Test by putting a piece of chopped onion n there. If it sizzles then you're good to go. Make sure the heat is on MEDIUM high, no higher! You don't want to burn the pieces. In the meantime, bring a kettle full of water to a boil.
Place oxtail pieces into pan, one by one. Fry the pieces evenly on both sides until they brown. This usually takes about 5 minutes. Keep checking, you don't want to blacken the pieces. Do not discard of the seasoning bowl or the remnants left in it. Set it aside for later.
Add in the ground seasonings to the pot except the scotch bonnet. Allow those to sauté with the browned oxtail pieces.
Once sautéed, pour about 3 cups of hot water from the kettle into the remaining seasoning left in the bowl. Mix the water and the seasonings with a spoon. Pour into the pot with oxtail, then add in the scotch bonnet pepper.
Cover with lid and allow to stew/cook down and simmer until the oxtail is tender. This will take about 3 hours. Continuously check if more hot water is needed but do not water down the gravy. Continuously check and taste for flavor.
Add in the carrots when there is about 1 hr left to cook.
Pour butter beans from can and rinse them off with water. Add them in when there are approximately 15 minutes left of cooking.
Serve with white rice, rice and peas, rasta pasta or mixed vegetables.